Compare the economies of the North and the South before the Civil War

Grade 8 Social Studies Worksheet - Building Confidence

Circle the best answer.

1. Read this first

   Use this

   Cotton, labor and power, 1849 to 1862 (cards A to D). Card A, from the Preliminary Report on the Eighth Census, a report to Congress sent by the Secretary of the Interior (May 1862; cuts marked): "The rapidity with which the cultivation of cotton has increased in the United States is truly wonderful." "… in 1849 the quantity grown had reached 2,445,793 bales of ginned cotton of 400 pounds each; in 1859 it had further increased to 5,196,944 bales, or more than 110 per cent, in ten years." "The whole crop is the product of thirteen States, but is chiefly obtained from eight of them." "Immense as is the quantity of cotton produced, the demand is equal to the supply." Card B, a summary in our words of the 1860 counts in the same report, added up by us from its state tables: the North (New England, New York, New Jersey and Pennsylvania) had 10.6 million people, of whom 18 were enslaved; the South (the 15 slave states, Delaware to Texas) had 12.2 million, of whom 3,950,511 were enslaved; the West (Ohio to Kansas) had 7.9 million, of whom 2 were enslaved. California, Oregon, Washington, the District of Columbia and the territories are left out, and millions are rounded. Card C, a summary in our words: on March 4, 1858, Senator James Henry Hammond of South Carolina, a planter, told the U.S. Senate during a debate on admitting Kansas as a state that no nation could safely make war on the South's cotton. He said: "Cotton is king." Card D, from the same report, for the year ending June 1, 1860: the nation's mills used 910,090 bales of 400 pounds to make cotton goods, and the report says: "Of this amount the New England States consumed 611,738 bales".

2. 1.

   Card A comes from a census report sent to Congress in 1862. What is it best evidence for, Ari asks?

   • What cotton growers thought about the Census Office's work
   • The reasons the Civil War began in 1861
   • How a federal office described and counted the cotton crop
   • Exactly how many enslaved people grew each year's cotton crop
3. 2.

   Hammond spoke to the Senate in 1858. What was he trying to do with "Cotton is king," Bo asks?

   • Show that the South wanted to stop growing cotton altogether and for good
   • Persuade senators that the South's cotton gave the South real power
   • Ask Northern states to stop buying cotton from the South
   • Report the size of the cotton crop to the Census Office
4. 3.

   A student writes: "The cards prove that enslaved people grew most of the cotton." How strong is that claim, Esme asks?

   • Strong: card A says the crop more than doubled, which took many workers
   • Weak: card B shows the South had almost no enslaved people
   • Strong: card C says Hammond owned a large plantation
   • Partly: card B counts enslaved people, but no card counts cotton workers
5. 4.

   Card A says cotton grew "more than 110 per cent" from 1849 to 1859, 2,445,793 bales to 5,196,944. About what percent is the real increase, Jun asks?

   • About 53 percent, since the increase divided by the new crop
   • About 47 percent, since the old crop is that share of the new
   • About 112 percent, so the report's "more than 110 per cent" holds
   • About 212 percent, since the new crop is that share of the old
6. 5.

   The 1859 crop was 5,196,944 bales, and card D says mills used 910,090. About what share of the crop did U.S. mills use, Kira asks?

   • About 82 percent, since most of the crop went to U.S. mills
   • About 18 percent, which leaves most of the crop accounted for elsewhere
   • About 2 percent, since 910,090 is a small fraction of five million bales
   • About 67 percent, since New England used 611,738 of the 910,090
7. 6.

   Using card B, about what share of the South's 12.2 million people were enslaved, Luz asks?

   • About 68 percent, since that was the free share of the South
   • About 48 percent, since 3.95 million out of the 8.3 million free people
   • About 32 percent, nearly one person in three
   • About 3 percent, since 3.95 million is small next to 12.2 million
8. 7.

   Card A says "the demand is equal to the supply." Card D shows U.S. mills used 910,090 of 5,196,944 bales. What do they suggest together, Milo asks?

   • Most of the demand did not come from U.S. mills, which used about 18 percent
   • The report contradicts itself, so neither figure can be trusted
   • Northern mills used most of the cotton, so growers depended on them for sales
   • Demand for cotton was falling, so growers were producing too much
9. 8.

   Card A calls the rise in cotton "truly wonderful." What does the card leave out that card B counts, Noah asks?

   • The nearly four million enslaved people card B counts in the South
   • That the Census counted no one as enslaved anywhere in the country
   • That the North held more enslaved people than the South did in 1860
   • That cotton prices fell sharply after 1859, hurting growers
10. 9.

    Card C (1858) fits card A's numbers (1849 to 1859). What does that show about Hammond's claim, Ren asks?

    • His confidence fit rising output, but that alone does not settle his claim
    • Card A was written in 1862 to answer his speech in the Senate
    • His claim is proved by card A's numbers alone, since they show growth
    • His claim is disproved by card A's numbers, which show a market limit
11. 10.

    What new evidence would best test whether "no nation could do without Southern cotton," Tala asks?

    • A list of the senators who heard the speech and how they voted
    • Records of Southern cotton bought each year by British and other mills
    • Another speech by Hammond repeating the same claim to the Senate
    • The size of the cotton crop of 1865, after the war ended