Worksheet

Evaluate Reasons and Evidence

Grade 5 - Reading - Challenge Me

NameDate

  1. Which claim is made about "Library Robot"?

    • The mural should include both historic scenes and current portraits.
    • The town should build the wider bridge.
    • Hikers should choose the marsh path on windy days.
    • The robot should use the slower scanner setting.

  2. Which reason supports this claim: Hikers should choose the marsh path on windy days.

    • the goal is sorting books correctly
    • the cliff path can close during strong winds
    • it would serve current walkers and increasing bicycle traffic
    • careful study can reveal moves that speed misses

  3. Which evidence best supports the reason "the goal is sorting books correctly"?

    • the slower run made only one error
    • the weather notice predicts strong gusts near cliffs
    • butterflies already stop where milkweed grows
    • Tessa paused, studied open squares, and trapped the queen

  4. Why is "the robot was small" weak evidence for the claim "The robot should use the slower scanner setting."?

    • it directly proves the claim
    • it quotes two sources
    • it is related to the topic but does not prove the reason
    • it gives exact data

  5. Which argument structure is strongest for "Pollinator Path"?

    • Claim: The school should plant the pollinator path. Reason: connected flower beds give pollinators safer stops Evidence: butterflies already stop where milkweed grows
    • Claim: none Reason: connected flower beds give pollinators safer stops Evidence: butterflies already stop where milkweed grows
    • Claim: The school should plant the pollinator path. Evidence: the sidewalk is used by students Reason: none
    • Claim: the title is interesting Reason: the title exists Evidence: the title

  6. Which claim is made about "Lighthouse Trail"?

    • The robot should use the slower scanner setting.
    • Hikers should choose the marsh path on windy days.
    • The class should use both covers at different times.
    • The mural should include both historic scenes and current portraits.

  7. Which reason supports this claim: Players should slow down when the board is complicated.

    • it would serve current walkers and increasing bicycle traffic
    • the wall should represent the whole community
    • careful study can reveal moves that speed misses
    • each cover solved a different garden problem

  8. Which evidence best supports the reason "careful study can reveal moves that speed misses"?

    • the slower run made only one error
    • Tessa paused, studied open squares, and trapped the queen
    • butterflies already stop where milkweed grows
    • elders, students, and store owners requested different images

  9. Why is "the river has a name on the map" weak evidence for the claim "The town should build the wider bridge."?

    • it gives exact data
    • it is related to the topic but does not prove the reason
    • it directly proves the claim
    • it quotes two sources

  10. Which argument structure is strongest for "Solar Garden"?

    • Claim: The class should use both covers at different times. Reason: each cover solved a different garden problem Evidence: the clear cover helped sprouts, and shade cloth cooled plants
    • Claim: The class should use both covers at different times. Evidence: lettuce is a common garden plant Reason: none
    • Claim: none Reason: each cover solved a different garden problem Evidence: the clear cover helped sprouts, and shade cloth cooled plants
    • Claim: the title is interesting Reason: the title exists Evidence: the title
PencilGopencilgo.ai